A note of warning, this list does change from time to time, some shows get added, others get a hard second look and get removed. But that doesn't mean that the list itself is less valuable that it was when you last saw it.
The rules are simple.
The show has to be fun on some level. That doesn't mean that it has to be funny. Though I did add a couple of campy shows on the list because, some guilty pleasures are allowed.
They are roughly grouped together by theme. But since a lot of them are over lapping you will see some broader genres being listed in "best fit" categories. This isn't an attempt to stick them in a different genre.
Sci-fi / Supernatural
- Continuum
- Orphan Black
- The 4400
- Alphas
- Ghost in the Shell
- Dollhouse
- The Twilight Zone
- Ascension
- Black Mirror
- The Outer Limits
- Alcatraz
- Sapphire & Steel
- Torchwood
- Flash Forward
- Threshold
- The Event
- Journeyman
- Warehouse 13
- Eureka
- Stargate Universe
- The Pretender
- Person of Interest
- Agents of SHEILD
Fantasy / Supernatural / Drama / Crime
This is a really wide range, a lot of things just don't fit in the above and I needed a catch-all for those hard to place stories.
- Eerie, Indiana
- Buffy the Vampire
- Twin Peaks
- Millennium
- Penny Dreadful
- Haven
- Lost Girl
- Sleepy Hollow
- Hannibal
- Supernatural
- Kolchak: The Night Stalker